Aquarium Water Conditioners: Why Tap Water Needs One

TankAndFin is reader-supported. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.
Every water change needs treated water. Below is why, according to the EPA and the University of Florida, and how Prime and Stress Coat differ. Product details come from Seachem, API and the Amazon listings. We didn't test either one.
Why tap water needs treating
The EPA: "Chlorine and monochloramine can be harmful to fish because they directly enter their bloodstream through the gills," and they "can also prevent the growth of beneficial bacteria." The good news, also from the EPA: treated water "can be safely used in aquariums by using products readily available from aquarium supply stores."
Chlorine vs chloramine
UF: "Chloramine is a combination of chlorine and ammonia. Sodium thiosulfate and aeration does NOT remove chloramines. A commercial product must be used." Seachem puts it simply: "chloramine minus chlorine = ammonia." That leftover ammonia is why some conditioners also claim to bind it. Your water utility can tell you which it uses.
Conditioners compared
| Seachem Prime | API Stress Coat | |
|---|---|---|
| Removes chlorine and chloramine | Yes | Yes |
| Detoxifies ammonia | Seachem's claim | Not claimed |
| Other | Detoxifies nitrite and nitrate (Seachem's claim) | Aloe vera for slime coat; detoxifies heavy metals (API) |
| Dose | 5 mL per 50 US gal of new water | 5 mL per 10 gal |
The ammonia, nitrite and nitrate claims are Seachem's own; we haven't found independent testing of them. A conditioner is not a substitute for a cycled filter or a water change when ammonia shows up. Full comparison: Seachem Prime vs API Stress Coat.
Seachem Prime (250 mL)
- Listing says it removes chlorine and chloramine
- Seachem says it also detoxifies ammonia, nitrite and nitrate (maker's claim)
- 5 mL treats 50 US gallons of new water
API Stress Coat (16 oz)
- Listing says it makes tap water safe
- Aloe vera to help replace the slime coat
- 5 mL per 10 gallons; double dose for damaged fins
Using it
- Seachem says to dose for the new water, and that each cap thread is about 1 mL for small volumes.
- If you refill with a faucet changer, Python says to add conditioner during refill. If you add it straight to the tank, dose for the whole tank volume (Seachem and API dose by water volume).
- Seachem says Prime "may be used during tank cycling" and "will not halt your cycling process." See cycling.
FAQ
Do I need a water conditioner for tap water?
Yes, if your water is chlorinated or chloraminated. The EPA says chlorine and monochloramine 'must be neutralized or removed if used in aquariums' because they enter fish's bloodstream through the gills.
What is chloramine?
A University of Florida fact sheet says chloramine 'is a combination of chlorine and ammonia,' and that aeration and sodium thiosulfate don't remove it; a commercial product must be used.
Can I just let tap water sit out?
UF says chlorine can be removed with vigorous aeration, but aeration does not remove chloramine. Use a conditioner.