Filters & Heaters

Aquarium Filters: Hang-On-Back, Canister or Sponge?

TankAndFin is reader-supported. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.

Short versionFor most 10 to 55 gallon tanks, a hang-on-back (HOB) power filter is the simple choice: Fluval's AC Series (formerly AquaClear) lists flow from 100 to 500 GPH and ships with all media; Aqueon's QuietFlow has a self-priming pump. For bigger or heavily stocked tanks, a canister holds more media. For bettas, a gentle sponge filter fits UF's advice on calm water.

The filter is where most of your tank's beneficial bacteria grow (Habitattitude notes gravel and decor host them too). Below is how the types differ, drawing on Habitattitude and the makers. Product details come from Fluval's and Aqueon's pages and the Amazon listings. We haven't tested these filters.

Three jobs a filter does

  • Mechanical: Habitattitude: mesh filters "remove larger particles and keep the water from becoming cloudy."
  • Chemical: filters that "remove waste products and elements that can be toxic to fish," usually with activated carbon.
  • Biological: "beneficial bacterial to break down toxic fish waste (ammonia, nitrite)." The University of Florida says a new biofilter needs "six to eight weeks" to build up enough bacteria.

How much flow?

Habitattitude: "an effective pump will circulate your entire tank's volume several times each hour." Bettas are the exception: UF says heavy filtration can stress them. For one tank size in detail, see our pick of the best filter for a 10 gallon tank, with each model's turnover worked out.

Hang-on-back filters compared

FilterTank sizeFlowNotes
Fluval AC205-20 gal100 GPHAll media included (Fluval)
Fluval AC3010-30 gal150 GPH
Fluval AC5020-50 gal200 GPH
Fluval AC7040-70 gal300 GPH
Aqueon QuietFlow 20Up to 30 gal (title)See boxSelf-priming; NoDrip cartridge
Aqueon QuietFlow 30Up to 45 gal (title)See boxCartridge-change LED
Marineland Penguin 150See box150 GPH (title)Rotating Bio-Wheel

Fluval figures from Fluval's AC Series page; others from the listings.

Fluval AC Series

Four-stage filtration with all media included, and a "CycleGuard" design: Fluval says changing one of the three media inserts at a time keeps bacteria levels stable. Fluval's site lists the AC Series alongside a legacy AquaClear archive.

Fluval AC50 Power Filter
20-50 gal, 200 GPH

Fluval AC50 Power Filter

  • Hang-on-back filter for 20-50 US gallons (title)
  • Media included (listing)
Check price on Amazon
Fluval AC70 Power Filter
40-70 gal, 300 GPH

Fluval AC70 Power Filter

  • Hang-on-back filter for 40-70 US gallons (title)
  • Media included (listing)
Check price on Amazon

Aqueon QuietFlow LED PRO

Aqueon lists 5-stage filtration with a slot for specialty pads (ammonia reducer, carbon or phosphate remover), a self-priming pump that restarts after power cuts, and a NoDrip cartridge holster.

Aqueon QuietFlow 20 LED PRO Power Filter
Up to 30 gal

Aqueon QuietFlow 20 LED PRO Power Filter

  • For tanks up to 30 gallons (title)
  • Listing: 5-stage filtration with specialty pad slot
  • Self-priming internal pump; NoDrip cartridge
Check price on Amazon
Aqueon QuietFlow 30 LED PRO Power Filter
Up to 45 gal

Aqueon QuietFlow 30 LED PRO Power Filter

  • For tanks up to 45 gallons (title)
  • LED flashes when the cartridge needs changing (listing)
  • Self-priming
Check price on Amazon

Marineland Penguin Bio-Wheel

Marineland's listing says the Bio-Wheel rotates for "wet/dry biological filtration."

Marineland Penguin 150 Bio-Wheel Filter
150 GPH, Bio-Wheel

Marineland Penguin 150 Bio-Wheel Filter

  • 150 GPH power filter (title)
  • Listing says the Bio-Wheel rotates for wet/dry biological filtration
  • Uses Rite-Size cartridges
Check price on Amazon

Maintenance

Don't replace everything at once. Fluval's BioMax listing says to replace only half the media at a time "to allow proper seeding." More in water changes and maintenance.

FAQ

What size filter do I need?

Habitattitude, backed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA, says an effective pump 'will circulate your entire tank's volume several times each hour.' Start with the maker's rated tank size; Aqueon says goldfish tanks should have a slightly oversized filter.

What are the three types of filtration?

Mechanical (catches particles), chemical (removes dissolved substances, often with carbon) and biological (bacteria that convert ammonia and nitrite). Habitattitude says biological filters take days or weeks to develop.

Should I replace all my filter media at once?

Fluval's listing for BioMax says to replace only half the filter media at a time to allow proper seeding, and Fluval's AC Series lets you change one of three inserts at a time to keep bacteria levels stable.

Sources

  1. UF/IFAS: Betta splendens care (FA212)
  2. Aqueon: Goldfish care guide
  3. Habitattitude: Tanks, equipment, maintenance
  4. Fluval: AC Series power filters
  5. Fluval: 07 Series canister filters
  6. Aqueon: PRO QuietFlow power filter
  7. UF/IFAS: Ammonia in aquatic systems (FA031)