Aquarium Substrate: Sand, Gravel or Plant Soil?

TankAndFin is reader-supported. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.
Substrate does more than cover the glass. Habitattitude notes that gravel and decor host some of the tank's beneficial bacteria, and DrTim's Aquatics says bare-bottom tanks take longer to cycle. Some substrates also change your water chemistry, which matters a lot for some fish and not at all for others. Below is how the main types differ, with grain size and pH effect from each maker or its retailer listing. We haven't run these substrates side by side.
Sand, gravel or soil
- Sand. Fine, smooth grains. CaribSea says its Super Naturals sands are free of dyes and paints and won't affect pH or hardness, and that the small, smooth grains are safer for bottom feeders and sand sifting invertebrates.
- Gravel. Larger pieces with more space between them. Seachem's Flourite Black is a porous clay gravel made for planted tanks. For goldfish, Aqueon advises against "jagged or crushed glass gravel," since goldfish forage in the substrate.
- Aqua soil. Granules made for planted tanks. UNS says Controsoil "buffers water to slightly acidic pH and lowers total water hardness," and Fluval says its Stratum supports a neutral to slightly acidic pH. Soils like these change your water on purpose, so they suit plants and soft water shrimp better than fish that want hard, alkaline water.
Substrates compared
| Substrate | Type | Grain size | Effect on pH and hardness | Made for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum | Volcanic soil | Not listed | Supports neutral to slightly acidic pH | Planted tanks, shrimp |
| UNS Controsoil | Soil and volcanic ash | Extra fine, fine and normal grades (no mm given) | Buffers toward pH 6.8; lowers hardness and KH | Planted tanks, shrimp |
| Seachem Flourite Black | Porous clay gravel | Not listed | Will not alter pH | Planted tanks |
| CaribSea Moonlight Sand | Natural sand | 0.25 to 0.75 mm | pH neutral; won't raise hardness | Community tanks, bottom feeders |
| CaribSea Crystal River | Natural sand | 0.5 to 1.0 mm | pH neutral; won't raise hardness | Community tanks, bottom feeders |
CaribSea grain sizes come from Bulk Reef Supply's CaribSea listings. The others come from the makers' pages and the Amazon listings.
Soil and pH: what to expect
UNS says Controsoil "successfully stabilizes pH levels to 6.8pH over time," which suits plants, many tropical fish and freshwater shrimp. It also says the soil releases "minimal amounts of ammonia" when new; in its own two week test without water changes, ammonia spiked after the sixth day, and UNS recommends weekly water changes. If you're keeping fish that prefer harder, alkaline water, an inert sand or gravel is the simpler match. Aqueon, for example, gives goldfish a pH of 7.0 to 8.4. Compare the numbers for your fish in aquarium water parameters.
How much to buy
For your own tank, the aquarium substrate calculator turns the footprint and the depth you want into liters, pounds of sand and bags. The makers' own guidance:
- Sand and gravel: CaribSea's listing recommends at least 1 lb per gallon of tank.
- Controsoil: UNS suggests 1 liter for a 2 gallon tank, 3 liters for a 9 gallon and 10 liters for a 20 gallon.
- Flourite: Seachem says a 7 kg bag fills about 320 cubic inches. Aqueon lists a standard 10 gallon tank at 20 1/4 x 10 1/2 inches, a footprint of about 213 square inches, so one 7 kg bag makes a bed about 1.5 inches deep (our arithmetic).
Setting it up
Seachem says to rinse Flourite to remove dust, and that some cloudiness can remain after rinsing; for an established tank it suggests adding small, rinsed amounts a half day to a day apart. The Controsoil listing says no rinsing is needed. Whatever you use, the tank still needs cycling before fish go in, because the substrate is only one surface for bacteria. See how to cycle a fish tank.
The substrates
Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum
A light, porous volcanic soil from the foothills of Japan's Mount Aso, per That Pet Place's product page. Fluval's listing says roots spread through it easily, it gives newborn shrimp somewhere to hide, and it won't discolor water.
Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum, 8.8 lb
- Porous volcanic soil for planted and shrimp tanks
- Supports a neutral to slightly acidic pH (listing)
- Gives newborn shrimp places to hide
UNS Controsoil
A soil and volcanic ash blend that UNS says is low in nutrients on purpose, to avoid big ammonia spikes in a new tank. It comes in extra fine, fine and normal grades, and black or brown.
UNS Controsoil, Black, Normal, 3 L
- Soil and volcanic ash blend for planted tanks
- Buffers toward pH 6.8 and lowers hardness (UNS)
- No rinsing needed (listing)
Seachem Flourite Black
A porous clay gravel that Seachem says isn't chemically coated, doesn't need laterite added, and lasts for the life of the aquarium. It can be used alone or mixed with other gravel.
Seachem Flourite Black, 3.5 kg
- Porous clay gravel for planted tanks
- Seachem: will not alter pH
- Rinse before use to remove dust
CaribSea Moonlight Sand and Crystal River
Two natural sands from CaribSea's Super Naturals line. Moonlight is a very fine, near white sand; Crystal River is a slightly coarser, light colored sand.
CaribSea Super Naturals Moonlight Sand, 2 x 5 lb
- Very fine natural sand, 0.25 to 0.75 mm
- pH neutral; won't raise hardness
- Listing suggests at least 1 lb per gallon
CaribSea Super Naturals Crystal River Sand, 40 lb
- Fine natural sand, 0.5 to 1.0 mm
- pH neutral, no paints or dyes
- Made in the USA (listing)
For goldfish, see goldfish tanks. If you're starting from scratch, aquarium starter kits shows what comes in each box.
FAQ
What is the best substrate for a planted tank?
An aqua soil or a porous plant gravel. Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum and UNS Controsoil are soils made for plants and shrimp that keep water neutral to slightly acidic. Seachem Flourite Black is a porous clay gravel that Seachem says works on its own as the substrate bed and will not alter pH.
Is sand or gravel better for an aquarium?
It depends on the fish. CaribSea sells its fine Super Naturals sands as smooth and safer for bottom feeders and sand sifters. For goldfish, Aqueon says to avoid jagged or crushed glass gravel because goldfish forage in the substrate. Natural sands like CaribSea's are sold as pH neutral.
Does aquarium soil lower pH?
Some soils do. UNS says Controsoil buffers water to a slightly acidic pH, stabilizing around 6.8, and lowers total hardness. Fluval says Plant and Shrimp Stratum supports a neutral to slightly acidic pH. Inert sands and Seachem's Flourite are sold as not changing pH.
How much substrate do I need?
CaribSea's listing recommends at least 1 lb of sand or gravel per gallon. UNS suggests 3 liters of Controsoil for a 9 gallon tank and 10 liters for a 20 gallon. Seachem says a 7 kg bag of Flourite fills about 320 cubic inches.
Sources
- Seachem: Flourite Black
- Ultum Nature Systems: Controsoil
- Bulk Reef Supply: CaribSea Super Naturals Moonlight Sand
- Bulk Reef Supply: CaribSea Super Naturals Crystal River
- That Pet Place: Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum
- Aqueon: Goldfish care guide
- Aqueon: Aquarium sizing information (PDF)
- Habitattitude: Tanks, equipment, maintenance
- DrTim's Aquatics: Quick guide to fishless cycling