Goldfish Tanks: Why the Bowl Has to Go

TankAndFin is reader-supported. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.
Goldfish are often sold as starter pets, but their needs surprise people, and a small goldfish today is not the fish you'll have in a few years. This page pulls together Aqueon's care guide and advice from federal and state agencies. Gear details come from the Amazon listings, not from our own testing.
How many gallons does a goldfish need?
At least 20 gallons for each adult common goldfish, comet or shubunkin, and at least 10 gallons for each adult fancy goldfish. Those are Aqueon's figures. RSPCA Australia adds a floor for any goldfish tank of 50 litres (about 13 US gallons), and says the tank should be at least four times as long as the adult fish, twice as wide and three times as tall.
| Goldfish | Aqueon minimum | With RSPCA's 50 litre floor |
|---|---|---|
| 1 fancy | 10 gal | About 13 gal |
| 2 fancy | 20 gal | 20 gal |
| 3 fancy | 30 gal | 30 gal |
| 1 common or comet | 20 gal | 20 gal |
| 2 common or comet | 40 gal | 40 gal |
By RSPCA's length rule, an 8 inch comet needs a tank at least 32 inches long, 16 inches wide and 24 inches tall (our arithmetic). Minnesota DNR says goldfish typically reach 5 to 8 inches, so plan for the adult fish, not the one in the store bag.
Common vs fancy goldfish
| Common, comet, shubunkin | Fancy (fantail, oranda, ryukin and others) | |
|---|---|---|
| Body | Long, single tail, fast swimmer | Round or egg-shaped, double tail, slower |
| Space per adult (Aqueon) | At least 20 gallons | At least 10 gallons |
| Temperature (Aqueon) | 60 to 70°F | 68 to 74°F |
| Long term | Long, roomy tank or a pond; outgrows most home aquariums | A large enough aquarium can be a long-term home |
Aqueon lists comets and shubunkins among the bred varieties and groups them with common goldfish for its space and temperature advice; the body-shape notes above are general descriptions to help you tell the groups apart.
Space
Aqueon: goldfish "should never be kept in bowls, small aquariums or any unfiltered container! In addition to having relatively high oxygen demands, they grow to be quite large and generate a significant amount of waste."
How large? Minnesota DNR says goldfish are typically 5 to 8 inches but "can reach close to 2 feet long," and USGS lists lifespans usually of 6 to 7 years with a recorded maximum of 30. Aqueon says properly cared-for goldfish "can live over 20 years." Gallons are only part of it: a long-bodied fish that size needs a tank long enough to turn and swim. We haven't found an extension or veterinary source that sets a minimum tank length, so for commons and comets, go as long as you can, and plan for a pond or a much bigger tank as they grow.
Temperature
Aqueon says fancy goldfish do best at 68 to 74°F, and comets and shubunkins at 60 to 70°F. UF notes high temperatures can stress coolwater fish like goldfish. Purdue's 4-H manual says goldfish "should not be placed with tropical fish."
Filtration and water changes
Aqueon: "The filter should be slightly over-sized to accommodate high waste production." It suggests changing 10% of the water weekly or 25% every two weeks, and feeding only what they eat in 2 to 3 minutes, once or twice a day. Cycle the filter before adding fish; see how to cycle a tank. If you travel, automatic fish feeders can hold that schedule while you're away.
For the bottom of the tank, Aqueon says to avoid "jagged or crushed glass gravel," since goldfish forage in the substrate. Grain sizes for smooth sands and gravels are compared in aquarium substrate.
Fluval 207 Canister Filter
- For aquariums up to 45 gallons (title)
- Listed as up to 25% quieter than before
- EZ-Lift media baskets
Fluval AC70 Power Filter
- Hang-on-back filter for 40-70 US gallons (title)
- Media included (listing)
The 29 gallon kit as a starting point
Tetra lists its 29 gallon kit at 30 x 12 x 18 inches, with a Whisper PF 30 filter and a 200W heater. How it fits depends on the fish:
- Fancy goldfish: by Aqueon's 10-gallons-per-adult figure, a 29 gallon tank can be a long-term home for two adult fancies.
- Common goldfish or comets: by Aqueon's numbers it fits one adult at most, and at 30 inches long it's short for a fish that can pass 8 inches. Treat it as a starting tank for one young fish, with a plan for something bigger, or a pond, later.
Aqueon's oversizing advice makes a bigger filter a sensible upgrade. The included heater may not be needed if your room stays within Aqueon's goldfish range.
Tetra 29 Gallon Aquarium Kit
- Listed at 30 x 12 x 18 in., glass, with LED hood
- Whisper PF 30 filter
- 200W heater and thermometer included
Aqueon Siphon Gravel Cleaner, Medium 9 in.
- Listed for aquariums 15 to 35 gallons
- Self-priming: up-and-down motion starts flow
- 6 ft hose with bucket clip
Never release goldfish
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says released goldfish "become an invasive species that can live for up to 25 years and do real harm to the water quality and wild fish communities." Minnesota DNR says goldfish "reproduce rapidly and can quickly number in the hundreds or thousands." Rehome them through a store, club or another hobbyist instead. See why you never release aquarium fish.
FAQ
How many gallons does a goldfish need?
It depends on the type. Aqueon recommends at least 20 gallons per adult common, comet or shubunkin goldfish, and at least 10 gallons per adult fancy goldfish. Commons and comets also need a long tank, and many eventually need a pond or a very large aquarium.
Is a 29 gallon tank big enough for goldfish?
For two adult fancy goldfish, yes by Aqueon's 10-gallons-per-adult figure. For common goldfish or comets it fits one adult at most and is short for a fish that can pass 8 inches, so treat it as a starting tank with a bigger home planned.
Can goldfish live in a bowl?
Aqueon says goldfish 'should never be kept in bowls, small aquariums or any unfiltered container' because they have high oxygen demands, grow large and produce a lot of waste.
How big do goldfish get?
Minnesota DNR says goldfish are typically 5 to 8 inches but can reach close to 2 feet long; USGS records a typical 120 to 220 mm standard length.